The Tasters Christmas menu: what to eat, which wines to pour

Countdown on: our community voted, and we turned its answers into a guide from apéro through dessert, with a bottle picked for every course.

Lionel Rudaz
Published
Updated
The Tasters Christmas menu: what to eat, which wines to pour

Champagne, a must for the Christmas apéro

Whatever your background, the tradition of opening a nice bottle of Champagne runs deep. If there's one time of year to treat yourself, it's the festive season, and our community confirms it: bubbles will be there at apéro time.

When we say Champagne, we mean it with a capital C, like the appellation for sparkling wines from Champagne, in France. For the Christmas apéro, you can go for smoked salmon or oysters. Either way, choose a Brut or Extra Brut, meaning wines with little sugar, lovely acidity and a slightly mineral edge. We recommend the house of Taittinger when the flutes come out, whether for its great classic, the Brut Réserve, or for the slightly more indulgent Prestige Rosé (which you can also bring out for dessert if there's fruit).

Brut Réserve
TaittingerBrut Réserve

France • Champagne • Champagne AOC

Pinot Noir, Pinot Meunier, Chardonnay

CHF 50.20

1 bottle of 75 cl

Prestige Rosé Brut
TaittingerPrestige Rosé Brut

France • Champagne • Champagne AOC

Pinot Noir, Pinot Meunier, Chardonnay

CHF 62.50

1 bottle of 75 cl

In our survey, Champagne came out on top to kick off Christmas Eve. Other Tasters stick with bubbles, but go for more affordable alternatives. For Catalan Cava, our heart goes to AUS Bruant 2021 from Alta Alella. Blending the traditional method with top-level organic viticulture, the Pujol-Busquets family wins us over with authentic wines that will please even demanding palates. For an even more affordable sparkler, we suggest the Asolo Prosecco Superiore Extra Brut from Tenuta Amadio. At this price, it's practically a gift: a lovely way to raise your glass.

Nature

AUS Bruant
Alta AlellaAUS Bruant 2021

Espagne • Catalogne • Cava DO

Xarel·lo

CHF 16.50

1 bottle of 75 cl

Asolo Prosecco Superiore Extra Brut
Tenuta AmadioAsolo Prosecco Superiore Extra Brut

Italie • Vénétie • Asolo Prosecco DOCG

Glera

CHF 15.60

1 bottle of 75 cl

And if bubbles aren't your thing, nothing beats a Chasselas from the shores of Lake Geneva. Hard to disagree: our emblematic regional wine works as well with canapés as with seafood or shellfish. We particularly like the St-Saphorin Vieilles Vignes 2024 from Domaine Bovy for its classic linden notes and controlled minerality, and the Calamin Grand Cru 2025 from Domaine Croix Duplex for its pleasant, almost salty bitterness.

St-Saphorin Vieilles Vignes
Domaine BovySt-Saphorin Vieilles Vignes 2024

Suisse • Vaud • Lavaux AOC

Chasselas

CHF 22.50

1 bottle of 70 cl

Calamin Grand Cru
Domaine Croix DuplexCalamin Grand Cru 2025

Suisse • Vaud • Calamin Grand Cru AOC

Chasselas

CHF 25.20

1 bottle of 70 cl

Our Christmas apéro, oyster and Champagne Taittinger Brut Réserve
Our Christmas apéro, oyster and Champagne Taittinger Brut Réserve

Salmon and Chablis for the starter

When we sit down at the table, we leave the bubbles aside and invite our guests to enjoy still wines that are anything but characterless.

The winning food and wine pairing in our survey is salmon with Sauvignon Blanc. Smoked or grilled, salmon always goes with a dry white. To fine-tune by cooking style, have a look at our wine and salmon pairings. Christmas dinner is the right time to bring out the great food whites, such as Burgundy Chardonnay, Rhône Viognier, Roussanne and Marsanne, or a Dézaley for a local touch. This year, our pick lands right in Burgundy, with the Chablis Per Aspera 2024 from Domaine Charly Nicolle. Straight and precise, this Chardonnay opens on summer flowers and fresh fruit, then on the iodine note typical of Chablis, with a fine balance between fruit and minerality. A bottle nobody stays indifferent to.

Chablis Per Aspera
Domaine Charly NicolleChablis Per Aspera 2024

France • Bourgogne • Chablis AOC

Chardonnay

CHF 23.20

1 bottle of 75 cl

It was half a surprise for us, but foie gras is still very popular over the holidays, despite growing concern for animal welfare. Pan-seared or spread on toast, it remains a typical Christmas dish that plenty of Tasters plan to enjoy with family. To go with it, we choose a vin doux naturel from Roussillon: Asphodèles 2021 from Domaine Madeloc, appellation Banyuls. White fruit, acacia blossom, hawthorn and a hint of lemon cake, then a rich palate where Grenache Gris and Malvasia linger. Serve it slightly cool, at 10 to 12°C.

Asphodèles
Domaine MadelocAsphodèles 2021

France • Roussillon • Banyuls AOC

Grenache Gris, Malvasia

CHF 18.00

1 bottle of 75 cl

Some tables will skip the salmon and foie gras for a good pasta dish, for example with seafood. In that case, we can't say it often enough: go for it with your eyes closed and your palate ready, with the Custoza Superiore Cà del Magro 2023 from Monte del Frà, in Veneto. This cuvée has won Gambero Rosso's Tre Bicchieri 17 years in a row (in Italian), and it's one of the sharpest white wines Italy has to offer. On top of that, great value for the pleasure it gives.

Custoza Superiore Cà del Magro
Az. Agr. Monte del Frà - Fam. BonomoCustoza Superiore Cà del Magro 2023

Italie • Vénétie • Custoza DOC

Chardonnay, Garganega, Cortese, Incrocio Manzoni, Procanico

CHF 17.20

1 bottle of 75 cl

For the starter, salmon and Chablis
For the starter, salmon and Chablis

Turkey or Wellington with a fine bottle of Bordeaux: it doesn't get better

For the main course, meat takes centre stage, and there are clearly two camps.

We're very traditional: turkey stuffed with truffles and chestnuts, mashed potatoes and Brussels sprouts. Turkey is fairly easy to pair, especially with flavourful sides. You can go for Pinot Noir or for bolder wines like Bordeaux blends.

On the other side sits beef Wellington. Between the puff pastry, the stuffing and the red meat, you'll need more structured wines, like a fine Rhône Syrah (a St-Joseph or a Côte-Rôtie), or a Sangiovese if you lean towards Italy.

Since our survey couldn't pick a winner, we suggest one festive bottle that suits both dishes: Le Petit Chevalier 2020, the second wine of Domaine de Chevalier, a blend of Cabernet Sauvignon, Merlot, Cabernet Franc and Petit Verdot. On the nose, fresh cherry meets spice; on the palate, it's full and generous, with crunchy fruit. A superb introduction to the Pessac-Léognan appellation. Decant it at least an hour before serving.

Le Petit Chevalier
Domaine de ChevalierLe Petit Chevalier 2020

France • Bordeaux • Pessac-Léognan AOC

Cabernet Sauvignon, Cabernet Franc, Merlot, Petit Verdot

CHF 36.00

1 bottle of 75 cl

For the main course, beef Wellington and Le Petit Chevalier
For the main course, beef Wellington and Le Petit Chevalier

The classic Christmas dessert: chocolate yule log and Amarone

When we launched our survey, one of our few certainties was that the bûche de Noël, the yule log, would win the dessert duel. Well, we got that completely wrong!

Tiramisu is the Tasters' favourite, and honestly, we get it. Still, it must be possible to make a tiramisu-flavoured yule log, right?

For our final pairing, we could have gone back to Champagne, maybe an indulgent rosé with a fruit dessert, or played it classic with an exceptional sweet wine. In the end, we went for Amarone. Why? Because we think a chocolate dessert like the yule log shows this wine at its best, and nothing beats it for stretching out the conversations around the table. It also makes a natural bridge to a little grappa or Armagnac as a digestif.

We know Amarone has its critics, but we stand by it. The Amarone della Valpolicella Classico 2020 from Monte del Frà is simply stunning: dried fruit, brandied cherries, ripe plum, liquorice and tobacco, then silky tannins. Remember to pour it into a carafe before serving. A wine to try and to share with the people you love.

Amarone della Valpolicella Classico DOCG
Az. Agr. Monte del Frà - Fam. BonomoAmarone della Valpolicella Classico DOCG 2020

Italie • Vénétie • Amarone della Valpolicella DOCG

Corvina, Rondinella, Corvinone

CHF 42.50

1 bottle of 75 cl

For dessert, cocoa yule log and Amarone della Valpolicella
For dessert, cocoa yule log and Amarone della Valpolicella

One last treat for the road? Which wine with panettone

The presents have been handed out and everyone is full, but there's one last sweet thing to enjoy with coffee: panettone. This Italian brioche filled with dried fruit (or plenty of other good things) and wonderfully buttery is gaining popularity after being mocked for decades. The artisan panettoni that end up on our plates are in a different league altogether.

Still warm from the oven (you'll thank us later 😉), there's only one wine to pair with panettone: a Moscato d'Asti. We chose the Prà Dône Moscato d'Asti 2025 from Cascina Galarin for a gentle finish.

With its straw-yellow colour, the tasting starts with your eyes. The nose then bursts with fresh floral aromas and exotic fruit. On the palate, the sweetness stays delicate, carried by lively acidity, and at just 5.5% alcohol it's incredibly light. You'll love it, and you might even win over guests who don't usually like sweet wines. 😋

Prà Dône Moscato d'Asti
Cascina GalarinPrà Dône Moscato d'Asti 2025

Italie • Piémont • Moscato d'Asti DOCG

Muscat Blanc

CHF 17.60

1 bottle of 75 cl

What a treat: buttery panettone with the fine bubbles of Moscato d'Asti.
What a treat: buttery panettone with the fine bubbles of Moscato d'Asti.

Finding the right gift for every wine fan

Before you fill up on good food and lovely bottles, don't forget the presents for your loved ones. We've got you covered: with Tasters, you'll find the perfect bottle, for example the best red wine to give, whether you stay sensible or want to splash out. And to cover the whole meal, from apéro to main course, get inspired by our ideas for a wine gift box with 3 bottles.

Know someone just starting out with wine? Turn to our Tasters Explorer subscription. With each delivery, it explores a new theme around 2 or 3 bottles picked by our sommeliers. You can give a gift voucher for 1, 2, 3, 6 or 12 months of subscription.

You have the ideas.
We have the perfect wine.

Tired of overthinking your wine choice? Just tell us in a few words why you need a bottle and we'll find the perfect wine in under a minute.

A dish, an occasion, a wine...